The NIH Research Center applications are in. The NIH is surely looking closely at how the chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS) research community responds. After all, they haven’t responded very well over time. A Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request indicated that the NIH receives few – really incredibly few – applications from ME/CFS researchers every year. (A blog on this is coming up). That surely didn’t inspire the uber competitive NIH to lay out a lot of money for research centers.
In fact, the NIH is probably asking itself whether the ME/CFS field is ready to produce effective research centers, and the funding probably reflects that concern. These are small Centers and there are not many of them in a field with so many needs. The research centers are a big opportunity and a big test for the ME/CFS research community. Is it up to the task?
A Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request suggested that it just might be. We don’t know how effective the research grant proposals the NIH received are, but the numbers were encouraging. The NIH received no less than 10 grant applications.
That’s more than expected, and indicates that some research groups outside the ME/CFS research mainstream or groups we didn’t expect to submit – did. Given the considerable time and effort it took to apply to become an NIH research center – ten applications is good news indeed.
Vicky Whittemore, the NIH liaison to ME/CFS and leader of the year-long effort to produce the research centers, said the Working Group that oversees ME/CFS research was pleased:
The Trans-NIH ME/CFS Working Group is pleased with the response to the ME/CFS RFA, which demonstrates an increasing interest in ME/CFS research from the research community.
Each application contains a major group and it’s collaborators. The grapevine suggests the identities of eight of the applicants and some of their collaborators appear to be:
- The Center for Enervating Neuroimmune Disease (Cornell) – Maureen Hanson + Dikomo Shungu + Sue Levine + the Workwell Foundation + Betsy Keller and ?
- The Center for Infection and Immunity – Ian Lipkin (+ Simmaron?) + ?
- The Genome Technology Center at Stanford – Ron Davis + Bob Naviaux + the Bateman-Horne Center
- Institute For Neuroimmune Medicine – Klimas, Broderick, Crawford, Rey and Vera + Shungu + ?
- Lenny Jason at DePaul University + the Ben Katz + ?
- The Nevada Center for Biomedical Research – Vincent Lombardi + De Meirleir + (probably Arizona State University)
- Pain and Fatigue Study Center – Benjamin Natelson + Dane Cook + Jarred Younger (or is Cook the principal?)
- Stanford Chronic Fatigue Initiative – Jose Montoya + Emory University + Jarred Younger
- The Jackson Laboratory (Connecticut) – Derya Unutmaz and the Bateman Horne Center – (added 6/5)
- Beth Isreal Deaconness Medical Center – Associated with Harvard Medical School – a multidisciplinary team headed up by Dr. Janet Mullington, a Ph.D. sleep researcher, all of whom are new to ME/CFS, is he final applicant. Mulligan found out about the application from Dr. Koroshetz.
(1) First Review – a panel of non-government experts will review each application for scientific and technical merit. This is expected to occur in late July/August. Who the all important reviewers for the applications are will be posted 30 days prior to the beginning of the review.
(2) Second Review – The Advisory Councils of each appropriate NIH Institute will review the applications for their relevance to the Institute’s goals and objectives in September. The winners will presumably be announced shortly afterwards.
(3) Funding provided – Vicky Whittemore hopes that funding will be provided to the grant winners as soon as possible after the Advisory Council meetings.
Early Winners – one early winner so far is the Solve ME/CFS Initiative (SMCI) which was asked to partner on so many of the applications that it will certainly be associated with one or more research centers. Another likely winner is the Bateman-Horne Center which was “a major clinical presence in the applications” and is partnered with Ron Davis, Derya Unutmaz, Ian Lipkin and Nancy Klimas.
Lots of Work
The three NIH research centers will have a lot to do and not a lot of money to do it with. They will be tasked with:
- Collaboration Emphasized – the centers are expected to bring in outside researchers and collaborate with each other. Unfortunately, they are also expected to pay the indirect costs for the institutions the researchers are associated with. Since those costs are about 40% of the researchers’ funding – they have the potential to put a big bite into research centers funds.
- Broad Sway – The Centers are given broad sway to come up with research proposals which inform “the etiology, pathogenesis and/or treatment of ME/CFS”.
- Longitudinal studies of individuals with ME/CFS in their own center and with other centers are expected; i.e. expect studies that follow patients over considerable periods of time in order to capture the heterogeneity and the core elements of ME/CFS.
- Information Portals – The Centers are expected to provide access to information on ME/CFS to researchers, academia and practicing doctors, healthcare professionals, patients, and the lay public (!).
Some other features of the Centers:
- The leader of each Center is expected to have “proven experience in the stewardship of large-scale research programs.”
- Clinical trials are not part of the research centers; however, each Center is expected to lay the groundwork for a treatment trial.
- All the data the research centers generate will be housed at a single Data Management and Coordinating Center (DMCC).
- Each Center will have to engage in at least one collaborative project with the other Centers. That will probably divert attention from what each Center considers their core mission, but it will create a large and hopefully illuminating study.
- Each Center will be required to propose two to three research projects.
- The administrative and reporting requirements are going to be weighty. One applicant expressed amazement at reporting requirements he/she felt were (a) much better suited to a larger center and would (b) chew up a lot of time and money. (Francis Collins recently agreed in testimony that these requirements in general should probably be relaxed).
The Research Centers are certainly a major step up but they’re hardly the cat’s meow. Each will have to spend money on a collaborative project that none might have chosen to do on their own. They will have to pay a steep price in the form of indirect costs for collaborating with outside researchers, and have to do quite a bit of reporting as well.
Each Center will start off with $1.2 million and perhaps have from $500 to $800K (???) a year to devote to their own specific research projects. That’s enough to pay for two or three large, complex studies a year per center. Plus a center-wide collaborative study will get done as well.
That offer was enticing enough for ten groups to apply. Hopefully, Ron Davis is right that the three centers are just a start and the NIH will build on them – giving each more money over time – and adding new centers to the fold. Time will tell!
The identity of the 9th applicant is known. Derya Unutmaz of the Jackson Laboratory in Connecticut is the principal investigator and he’s teaming up with the Bateman-Horne Center. Unutmaz is the just the kind of researcher we hoped this grant opportunity would attract. He’s well established, works at a hot lab and has a background in ME/CFS as well.
The last missing group is from Jackson Genomic Medicine, I am the PI and as you would expect it’s in close collaboration with Bateman Horne center. I think we put together an outstanding team of experts on microbiome, immunology, metabolism, clinical, computational and bioinformatics analysis -that has the possibility of creating something transformative.
Actually, I would say this is one of the most exciting grants and teams I had the fortune to assemble, despite the arduous process of putting it together.
One more application to go. Who is the missing group?
Register for our free ME/CFS, fibromyalgia, and long COVID blogs here.