“Creating a scientific culture that compels consideration of sex in shaping the immune response is essential to a comprehensive understanding of health and disease.”
The female predominance in autoimmune disorders (greater than 85% female in Sjogrens, lupus, Addison’s disease, and scleroderma, plus 60-75% female in rheumatoid arthritis) is well known, yet studies examining why this is so are remarkably rare. The researchers in this review article suggest it’s about time to look at this pattern more closely.
The authors didn’t note an equally strong female bias in fibromyalgia or chronic fatigue syndrome or in cardiovascular disorders such as postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome (POTS) and orthostatic hypotension (OH) which also appear to be autoimmune in nature.
The question is why women tend to come down with autoimmune disorders and what insights this might provide for the female gender dominant (and possibly autoimmune) disorders such as chronic fatigue syndrome and fibromyalgia.
Stronger More Complex Immune System in Women Has a Downside
Their stronger and more complex female immune system results in women being less susceptible to infection, but once women get an infection they appear to have more trouble recovering from it. The high predominance of women in post-infectious mononucleosis (IM) triggered ME/CFS suggests, for instance, that men recover much more easily from IM than do women.
Not only are women much more inclined to get an autoimmune disorder, but they also get them at an earlier age. Lupus typically occurs 5-10 years earlier in women than men.
Plasmcytoid dendritic cells (pDC’s), macrophages, invariant Natural Killer Cells are all parts of the innate immune system that appear to be highly influenced by female hormones. Each provides the opportunity for drug development options that target an over-active immune system.
It’s not just the woman’s immune system, however; research suggests that the complex interaction between their hormones and their immune system plays a role.
The Effect of Female Hormones
The authors suggested that high hormone levels (estrogen) affect an inflammatory regulator that could push the system towards autoimmunity and account for the female dominance in lupus. Recent research also suggests estrogen regulation of B-cells may set the stage for rheumatoid arthritis.
On the other hand the higher progesterone levels during pregnancy appear to confer protective immune effects involving Treg cells (see below). I know of one person whose ME/CFS was reduced markedly with progesterone.
Several studies have not found levels of estrogen or progesterone in ME/CFS or Fibromyalgia. One study did find evidence of increased progesterone metabolites in ME/CFS.
Gordon Broderick’s models suggest the issue is more complex that simply high or low hormone levels. They suggest females are more likely to get stuck with ME/CFS because their sex hormones are more likely to push the HPA axis and immune system into a suboptimal steady state. Broderick’s model of chronic fatigue syndrome requires both high hormone levels (estradiol) and a malfunctioning HPA axis.
In his attempts to map out the interactions that cause disease Broderick is ploughing new ground not just in ME/CFS and GWI, but in the medical field generally. He’s focused on identifying ‘breakpoints’ that can be manipulated which will tilt the system back to normal. These breakpoints are not necessarily synonymous with abnormal levels of a hormone or cytokine, but sometimes involve substances that are found in normal levels that nevertheless have a dramatic effect on a dysregulated immune or other network.
Protective Effects of Testosterone
In Broderick’s model, male hormones protect men from coming down with ME/CFS, and some evidence suggests the same is true for autoimmune disorders.
Declining testosterone levels in men as they age may place them more at risk for rheumatoid arthritis and multiple sclerosis. They may also be responsible for the gender parity seen in RA by age 75, and could explain why men tend to get multiple sclerosis at a later age than women. Low testosterone levels played an important role in Broderick’s model of Gulf War Illness (but not ME/CFS) as well. Low androgen levels in both men and women also appear to put them at risk for autoimmune disorders. Castrating mice results in them having higher incidences of autoimmune disorders.
The evidence for the protective effects of testosterone for autoimmune disorders is preliminary, but alternative health practitioners often find low testosterone levels in men with ME/CFS and prescribe testosterone for them.
Immune Shifts During Pregnancy Provide Clues
“While many studies of autoimmune and infectious disease pathogenesis report changes in immunological factors over the course of pregnancy, few studies consider the role that hormones play in orchestrating these immunological changes” Robinson and Klein
Autoimmune disorders often go into remission during pregnancy but then worsen in the postpartum period. From half to three quarters of pregnant women with RA go into partial or even full remission during pregnancy. Doctors report that about 30% of pregnant mothers with ME/CFS experience significant remissions, perhaps suggesting that as many as 60% may have an autoimmune disorder.
Check out the Pregnancy Talk video to listen to a woman whose severe ME/CFS almost completely disappeared during each of her three pregnancies, and the comments indicating that some women with ME/CFS get worse. One study suggested that most women with fibromyalgia get worse, not better, during pregnancy.)
The question, of course, is why some women with autoimmune disorders and ME/CFS feel so much better during pregnancy (and is there a way to bottle that?). Hormones clearly have a role, and so does the immune system.
During pregnancy a woman’s immune system undergoes vast shifts as it develops a tolerance for a fetus that differs markedly from it, and as it shifts to a more anti-inflammatory profile. It makes sense that an autoimmune disorder might wane as a pregnant woman’s immune system pulls back on its immune surveillance of ‘other’ cells.
The downside of this is that as a woman’s immune surveillance wanes during pregnancy their incidence of infection increases (suggesting an infection could play a role in women for whom pregnancy triggered their ME/CFS).
Thus far there are some clues but no concrete answers. Elevated frequencies of T regulatory cells that peak in the second trimester could play a role and provide a link to ME/CFS. Altered levels of Treg, NK, B, and T-cells in a recent ME/CFS study led the authors to propose that the ‘significant impairments in immune regulation‘ found may be similar to those found in autoimmune disorders.
Treg cells protect the fetus from rejection, and reduced levels of Treg cells in mice are associated with increased rates of arthritis. Researchers were able to protect mice that were susceptible to arthritis simply by transferring Treg cells from pregnant mice to them.
Microbiome (Gut Flora)
“Given that considerable resources in immunology research are directed towards animal models, the necessity to include male and female study subjects in investigations should be the norm. Regrettably, this is not the case, largely because of the associated costs and the diminishing research funding. Consequently, the critical relevance of sex to an immune response continues to be ignored.”
A fascinating study shows no gender differences in microbiomes in mice until the mice reach puberty and become more different as they become adults. A similar study of opposite sex and same sex twin pairs found similar gut microbiomes in infancy in both groups, similar gut flora’s in the same sex twins during puberty but differences in the opposite sex twins when they reached puberty.
These studies suggest the large hormonal fluctuations occurring in females during puberty (and menstruation and pregnancy?) affect their microbiomes. The fact that these twins were eating the same foods and lived in the same environment suggest the microbiome changes were largely driven by hormones (and suggested females are perhaps predisposed to less optimal microbiomes)?
Antibiotic use has also been shown to alter the metabolism of hormones in the gut. (A recent Natural Resource Defense Counsel report stated that none of the antibiotics given to chicken would pass muster under current FDA rules, and asserts the FDA has utterly failed to address the question of antibiotics in animal feeds.)
Adding the contents of male mice microbiomes to female mice predisposed to diabetes reduced the female mice incidence of type I diabetes. Interestingly, the protective element again appeared to be testosterone, the levels of which were highly influenced by the composition of the mouse gut flora. Just as hormones appear to be able to gut then, gut composition appears to be able to affect hormone production.
The microbiome’s effects on diabetes in this mouse model are so evident now that the authors stated it’s clear that the incidence of diabetes in a mouse model is dependent on the mouse’s microbiome.
Recently we saw that the gut flora of newly diagnosed rheumatoid arthritis patients was dominated by a single bacterium. See Study suggests gut bacteria may be able to trigger autoimmune disorders.
These early efforts and those indicating gluten intolerance is a risk factor for autoimmunity suggest the gut may play a significant role.
Menstrual Cycle and Gynecological Disorders
Despite the lack of positive hormonal findings, gynecological and menstrual cycle issues suggest female hormones play a role in both ME/CFS and FM.
Gynecological problems appear to be increased in both disorders. The CDC’s 2011 ME/CFS study findings of significantly increased incidence of pelvic pain, endometriosis, amenorrhea, and gynecological surgeries suggest that women’s hormonal systems have gone awry.
Pregnant women with fibromyalgia had higher rates of intrauterine growth restriction (7.1% vs. 1.0%, p = 0.001), recurrent abortions (9.8% vs. 1.8%, p < 0.001), gestational diabetes mellitus (14.3% vs. 7%, p = 0.012), and polyhydramnios (12.5% vs. 1.6%, p < 0.001).
A recent study andan older study found that symptom flares occurred frequently prior to the onset of menses in women with fibromyalgia, lupus, or rheumatoid arthritis suggest the three disorders share some common features.
“Although there is accumulating observational data that describe the importance of the effects of sex hormones on immune cells and their function, there is a paucity of mechanistic data, which would inform/translate these observations into clinical utility.”
It’s amazing how little researchers know about the effects of gender on autoimmune and other diseases such as ME/CFS and FM, given the high female dominance and the likelihood that important answers are waiting to be uncovered. Still, the research that has been done presents some enticing leads.
Women may come down with ME/CFS for the same reason that they are more at risk for autoimmune disorders; while their more complex immune and hormonal systems provide them protection from infection, they may also may provide more opportunity for ‘breakdowns’. Fairly strong evidence suggests female hormonal shifts may effect gut composition which in term may then affect both the hormonal and immune systems.
It’s encouraging that Broderick’s modeling efforts for GWI and ME/CFS fit current understanding of the effects of hormones on the immune system and expand on them. It appears that ME/CFS and GWI are the first disorders to benefit from this modeling approach.
High estrogen levels may set the stage for autoimmune disorders, but may not be found in either ME/CFS or FM. Broderick’s model of ME/CFS persistence, however, does target estradiol and higher than normal levels of a substance are not always needed for it to have a dramatic effect if other parts of the system are dysregulated.
The still preliminary but increasing evidence that testosterone may play such a protective role for men was notable. The increased activity of the Treg cells during pregnancy (and perhaps a corresponding reduction in symptoms) is intriguing given recent evidence that these immune cells are not up to snuff in ME/CFS. A similar situation may be evolving with regards to B-cells. We’ll surely hear more regarding both these cells from the NCNED in Australia.
When a major breakthrough in understanding or treating ME/CFS or FM takes place you’ll hear about it quickly and completely on Health Rising. Just $5 dollars a month – an amount most people wouldn’t notice – from enough people will keep us on the web and publishing. You won’t notice the $5 but we will. Find out more here.